QB · NYG · Age 23.6 · Bye 8
| Profile | Value | Overall rank | Pos. rank |
|---|---|---|---|
| Superflex | 11 | #188 | #35 |
| 1QB | 13 | #163 | #22 |
| TE Premium | 13 | #163 | #22 |
2026: 0.2 PPG over 1 games · Projected 6.2 PPG. Values on the 0–1,000 scale; recompute against live market ADP in our trade calculator.
Players closest to J.J. McCarthy by superflex trade value (same position preferred).
Our model values J.J. McCarthy at 11 on the Dynasty Formula 0–1,000 scale in superflex, 13 in 1QB and 13 in TE premium. That places him in the dart-throw / bench tier.
J.J. McCarthy ranks 188th overall in superflex (35th among QBs), 163rd in 1QB and 163rd in TE premium.
We don't do blanket buy/sell calls. It depends on your roster and the price. On value alone, J.J. McCarthy is in the dart-throw / bench tier as a 23.6-year-old QB. Run him through the trade calculator to see what it takes to get him.